Here’s a bold statement: Islam Makhachev is stepping into uncharted territory by eyeing a fight with Kamaru Usman, and it’s sparking a debate that’s dividing the MMA world. But here’s where it gets controversial—while many believe Usman doesn’t deserve this shot, others argue it’s the most dangerous and logical challenge for Makhachev. Let’s break it down.
Islam Makhachev has been unwavering in his desire to face Kamaru Usman as his next opponent, even as he prepares to defend his 170-pound title. This decision hasn’t sat well with everyone, especially considering the other contenders vying for a shot at the belt. And this is the part most people miss—Makhachev himself acknowledges that this is a ‘big step up in competition,’ a move that could either solidify his dominance or expose vulnerabilities.
Belal Muhammad, for instance, has openly criticized Usman, claiming he doesn’t deserve this opportunity after turning down other matchups earlier this year. Yet, Jorge Masvidal, a fighter who knows Usman’s capabilities all too well, disagrees. On his Death Row MMA podcast, Masvidal boldly stated, ‘I think this is the most dangerous fight for Makhachev at 170.’ He pointed to Usman’s exceptional wrestling defense and ability to counter grapplers as a significant threat to Makhachev’s reign.
Masvidal’s argument isn’t just hype. He highlights Usman’s legacy and skill set, particularly his defensive prowess, as reasons why this fight makes sense—even if it’s not the popular choice. Meanwhile, Usman’s manager doubles down, arguing that his fighter’s accomplishments should earn him the first crack at the new champion. Here’s the kicker—Usman recently snapped a three-fight losing streak with a win over Joaquin Buckley, proving he’s still a force to be reckoned with.
But let’s not forget Georges St-Pierre’s insights. During a recent interview, GSP explained that to beat someone like Makhachev, you need to match his wrestling and win the striking exchanges. Masvidal believes Usman is one of the few who could pull this off, making the matchup even more intriguing—though many fans remain skeptical.
Now, here’s the controversial question: Does Kamaru Usman truly deserve this title shot after his recent setbacks, or is Makhachev biting off more than he can chew? And if not Usman, who should step into the octagon next? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below. Join the debate, share your insights, and let’s keep this conversation going!
